After my re-read of this classic, I give Carmilla 3.5 stars. I loved the atmosphere and the language, even if I thought it was a bit too flowery at times.
I know that it's wrong to judge a work of this age by today's standards, but man, everyone in this book seemed stupid and too naive to be believable. The whole time, I was thinking "My God, man, wake up!"
I'm glad I re-read this one but I think that shall be it for me with Carmilla.