I'm adopting the original post from Kitty Horror. Thanks for the idea!
There aren't any surprises here. I think the main surprise for me was not seeing The Godfather on anyone else's list! Anyway, it's #1 on my list and I don't see that ever changing.
2. The Godfather Part II.
3. Goodfellas. Do you see a pattern here?
4. The Shawshank Redemption. Nothing needs to be said about this excellent movie.
5. Rear Window. Jimmy Stewart. Grace Kelly. Alfred Hitchcock. Nuff said.
6. The Big Lebowski
7. This is Spinal Tap. Hello, Cleveland!
8. Night of the Living Dead
9. The Departed